Artificial Intelligence (AI) writing tools such as ChatGPT present a challenge for educators who wish to maintain the integrity of the learning process. While some argue that these tools can be helpful, others point out their potential for fostering academic dishonesty. This article examines various strategies educators can implement to create AI-proof assignments, ensuring that students demonstrate original thought and avoid relying on algorithms for their work.
Table of Contents
Encourage Personal and Reflective Writing
Educators may assign writing tasks emphasizing personal experiences, emotions, or decisions. AI writing tools typically struggle to generate content depicting unique personal stories convincingly. However, balancing individual writing assignments and those that encourage critical thinking skills is essential.
Focus on Local or Community Issues
Assignments rooted in local or community-driven topics can limit ChatGPT’s effectiveness since the AI tool may need help to answer questions about hyperlocal subjects. Examples include discussing a school-specific event or researching local environmental issues.
Discuss Recent News or Events
ChatGPT and similar AI tools rely on large datasets, often needing more up-to-date information. Consequently, assignments requiring students to analyze recent events may require more work for ChatGPT to generate content accurately.
Require Students to Show Their Work
Teachers can ask students to provide an account of their writing process, detailing their brainstorming, structuring, and decision-making steps. By encouraging students to explain their writing strategies, educators can hold them more accountable for their work.
Combine Written Work with Oral Presentations
Integrating oral presentation components into assignments may encourage students to rely on AI tools. Platforms like Canva provide opportunities for students to discuss their written work, fostering a greater understanding of the subject matter.
Reintroduce Handwritten Assignments
Incorporating traditional, handwritten essays or in-class writing activities reduces the chance of students seeking assistance from AI programs, ensuring that the work remains their own.
Encourage Project-Based Learning
Complex, interdisciplinary projects require comprehensive understanding and engagement, making it unlikely that a student would want to rely solely on generated content. These projects demand active participation, reducing the appeal of automated support.
Pre-Test the Assignment with ChatGPT
Educators can use ChatGPT to attempt their assignment prompts before assigning them. This strategy helps reveal potential loopholes that allow students to devise ChatGPT-generated responses. By anticipating the limitations of the AI tool, teachers can design more authentic and rigorous assignments.
Incorporate Peer Evaluation and Collaboration
Incorporating peer evaluations and group work into assignments fosters collaboration and active participation, making it more challenging for students to rely on AI-generated content. By sharing and critiquing each other’s work, students may develop a sense of ownership over their original ideas, reducing the temptation to seek help from AI tools.
Use Multimodal Assignments
Integrating various modes of communication into assignments, such as text, images, audio, or video, can help increase the difficulty of AI-generated responses. Multimodal tasks require students to exercise creativity and critical thinking across different formats, limiting the efficacy of AI tools like ChatGPT.
Create Prompts that Require Reflection on Classroom Discussions
Customize assignments to reflect specific classroom discussions or activities. AI writing tools cannot reproduce detailed information from real-world interactions, making it difficult for students to find relevant AI-generated answers for unique classroom experiences.
Implement Time Constraints and In-Class Writing
In-class writing exercises with time constraints reduce the opportunity for students to consult AI tools. By limiting the time and resources available, teachers can encourage students to rely on their knowledge, critical thinking, and creativity.
Require Annotations and Citations
Ask students to provide annotations or detailed citations for their written work. This approach encourages them to engage with primary sources, providing context and support for their ideas beyond what AI tools might generate without guidance.
Assign Creative Writing Exercises
Promote imaginative tasks by assigning creative writing exercises such as poetry, short stories, or scripts. These formats demand unique perspectives, voices, and styles that are more difficult for AI tools to replicate convincingly.
Integrate Self-Assessment and Reflection
Incorporate self-assessment and reflection components into assignments, asking students to evaluate their work, identify strengths and weaknesses, and discuss the learning process. These reflective practices help students build ownership over their learning, reducing the likelihood of using AI-generated content.
By implementing these strategies in assignment design, educators can create more AI-proof tasks that demand genuine thought and effort from students. The goal is to prevent the misuse of AI tools and ensure that students develop the critical thinking and problem-solving skills essential for their academic growth.
READ: Limitations of AI-generated Text Detection: Implications for Educators and Education Professionals